Skip to main content

Yesterday I brought the story of John Napier Tye to Dailykos but it scrolled off rather quickly so I thought I would have another go, adding this bonus article from the Atlantic on the story. But first, a quick recap:

In the July 18th Edition of the Washington Post John Napier Tye, the State Departments former Section Chief on Internet Freedom in the departments Bureau of Human Rights and Labor posted an important op-ed concerned that the Reagan era executive order poses a direct risk to our democracy. While this is not surprising to those of us who have followed the NSA's success at narrowing the discussion down to various Patriot Act sections, it is important that someone of such credentials is bringing the discussion to the public.
From 2011 until April of this year, I worked on global Internet freedom policy as a civil servant at the State Department. In that capacity, I was cleared to receive top-secret and “sensitive compartmented” information. Based in part on classified facts that I am prohibited by law from publishing, I believe that Americans should be even more concerned about the collection and storage of their communications under Executive Order 12333 than under Section 215

Tye explains the differences between section 215 and EO 12333 and hints at how much information is captured:

Unlike Section 215, the executive order authorizes collection of the content of communications, not just metadata, even for U.S. persons. Such persons cannot be individually targeted under 12333 without a court order. However, if the contents of a U.S. person’s communications are “incidentally” collected (an NSA term of art) in the course of a lawful overseas foreign intelligence investigation, then Section 2.3(c) of the executive order explicitly authorizes their retention. It does not require that the affected U.S. persons be suspected of wrongdoing and places no limits on the volume of communications by U.S. persons that may be collected and retained.

“Incidental” collection may sound insignificant, but it is a legal loophole that can be stretched very wide. Remember that the NSA is building a data center in Utah five times the size of the U.S. Capitol building, with its own power plant that will reportedly burn $40 million a year in electricity.

“Incidental collection” might need its own power plant.

Using careful wording Tye careful treads the line between revealing too much but pointing people in the right direction at the same time.
All of this calls into question some recent administration statements. Gen. Keith Alexander, a former NSA director, has said publicly that for years the NSA maintained a U.S. person e-mail metadata program similar to the Section 215 telephone metadata program. And he has maintained that the e-mail program was terminated in 2011 because “we thought we could better protect civil liberties and privacy by doing away with it.” Note, however, that Alexander never said that the NSA stopped collecting such data — merely that the agency was no longer using the Patriot Act to do so. I suggest that Americans dig deeper.
I was quite pleased this morning to google Tye's name and see this fresh story from The Atlantic come up:
New Surveillance Whistleblower: The NSA Violates the Constitution

John Napier Tye is speaking out to warn Americans about illegal spying. The former State Department official, who served in the Obama administration from 2011 to 2014, declared Friday that ongoing NSA surveillance abuses are taking place under the auspices of Executive Order 12333, which came into being in 1981, before the era of digital communications, but is being used to collect them promiscuously. Nye alleges that the Obama administration has been violating the Constitution with scant oversight from Congress or the judiciary.

"The order as used today threatens our democracy," he wrote in The Washington Post. "I am coming forward because I think Americans deserve an honest answer to the simple question: What kind of data is the NSA collecting on millions, or hundreds of millions, of Americans?"

While EO 12333 is not news to those who spend time around this site or follow Marcy Wheeler, it is a BFD that someone of such credentials is speaking out. With no ties to Russia, Snowden or Greenwald he will not be as easy a target for smearing/deflecting. From Tye:
When I started at the State Department, I took an oath to protect the Constitution of the United States. I don’t believe that there is any valid interpretation of the Fourth Amendment that could permit the government to collect and store a large portion of U.S. citizens’ online communications, without any court or congressional oversight, and without any suspicion of wrongdoing. Such a legal regime risks abuse in the long run, regardless of whether one trusts the individuals in office at a particular moment.
And then back to that Atlantic article discussing this statement:
This act of conscience illuminates yet another path a surveillance whistleblower can take. If more current and former federal officials believe the NSA is in flagrant violation of the Fourth Amendment, they should consider declaring themselves too. "Based in part on classified facts that I am prohibited by law from publishing," Tye wrote, "I believe that Americans should be even more concerned about the collection and storage of their communications under Executive Order 12333 than under Section 215." I wonder what he saw but isn't revealing.

6:52 AM PT: Link to an article in US News in which Tye discusses his role, with quotes from Dailykos's Jesselyn Radack, and Tye himself:

“The way the government has treated whistleblowers like Thomas Drake, who went through every possible internal channel and still got prosecuted for espionage, I certainly worry that the government may retaliate, probably by never hiring Mr. Tye or giving him a security clearance again,” Radack tells U.S. News.

Tye, however, isn’t concerned.

“I don’t think there should be any retribution in this case because I haven’t broken any laws,” he says. “I took an oath to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States and this is part of that effort. I haven’t disclosed classified information to anyone who was not authorized to receive it, and I followed the law the whole way through.”

He also believes many executive branch employees agree with him that the order allows for violations of Americans’ Fourth Amendment rights and expects President Barack Obama to come around after reviewing the issue.

“I’m not worried about retribution because I think the government will do the right thing on this,” he says. “I think that the president, once he understands the scale of constitutional problems from 12333, will agree that we need a change…He could do it with the stroke of his pen by amending the executive order.”

Originally posted to LieparDestin on Tue Jul 22, 2014 at 04:40 AM PDT.

Also republished by Progressive Policy Zone.

Your Email has been sent.
You must add at least one tag to this diary before publishing it.

Add keywords that describe this diary. Separate multiple keywords with commas.
Tagging tips - Search For Tags - Browse For Tags


More Tagging tips:

A tag is a way to search for this diary. If someone is searching for "Barack Obama," is this a diary they'd be trying to find?

Use a person's full name, without any title. Senator Obama may become President Obama, and Michelle Obama might run for office.

If your diary covers an election or elected official, use election tags, which are generally the state abbreviation followed by the office. CA-01 is the first district House seat. CA-Sen covers both senate races. NY-GOV covers the New York governor's race.

Tags do not compound: that is, "education reform" is a completely different tag from "education". A tag like "reform" alone is probably not meaningful.

Consider if one or more of these tags fits your diary: Civil Rights, Community, Congress, Culture, Economy, Education, Elections, Energy, Environment, Health Care, International, Labor, Law, Media, Meta, National Security, Science, Transportation, or White House. If your diary is specific to a state, consider adding the state (California, Texas, etc). Keep in mind, though, that there are many wonderful and important diaries that don't fit in any of these tags. Don't worry if yours doesn't.

You can add a private note to this diary when hotlisting it:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from your hotlist?
Are you sure you want to remove your recommendation? You can only recommend a diary once, so you will not be able to re-recommend it afterwards.
Rescue this diary, and add a note:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary from Rescue?
Choose where to republish this diary. The diary will be added to the queue for that group. Publish it from the queue to make it appear.

You must be a member of a group to use this feature.

Add a quick update to your diary without changing the diary itself:
Are you sure you want to remove this diary?
(The diary will be removed from the site and returned to your drafts for further editing.)
(The diary will be removed.)
Are you sure you want to save these changes to the published diary?

Comment Preferences

Meteor Blades, bink, Alumbrados, Angie in WA State, cslewis, Mimikatz, nota bene, Bollox Ref, Garrett, RF, jps, Chi, Odysseus, copymark, teacherken, Trendar, glitterscale, Liberal Thinking, native, Gooserock, mimi, emal, Shockwave, just another vet, wu ming, Pescadero Bill, CleverNickName, genethefiend, hyperstation, OLinda, TX Unmuzzled, saluda, xynz, RFK Lives, gjohnsit, niemann, Creosote, Heart of the Rockies, Dumbo, Babsnc, TracieLynn, cskendrick, Einsteinia, susakinovember, ask, boadicea, chuckvw, phillies, rabel, ovals49, Boston to Salem, jalbert, corncam, Bill Roberts, Nate Roberts, Iberian, splashy, kharma, scorpiorising, psnyder, minorityusa, Dallasdoc, CitizenOfEarth, ranger995, white blitz, Catte Nappe, Kristin in WA, supenau, lcrp, wordwraith, riverlover, Dood Abides, dkmich, zerelda, WisVoter, Deward Hastings, ScienceMom, Mosquito Pilot, mosesfreeman, solesse413, Frank Vyan Walton, oortdust, sawgrass727, nailbender, Skennet Boch, davidincleveland, G2geek, kbman, bobdevo, tovan, Bluesee, eastsidedemocrat, radarlady, 3goldens, jrooth, UncleCharlie, LakeSuperior, CTPatriot, corvo, run around, Simplify, DocGonzo, eightlivesleft, basquebob, dewtx, ChemBob, YucatanMan, Byrnt, fixxit, eru, SaraBeth, Sun Tzu, Dem Beans, GreyHawk, Kayakbiker, lotlizard, stevemb, most peculiar mama, markdd, Ozymandius, RichterScale, Sandino, kaliope, Tool, Shotput8, Ginny in CO, sodalis, Lisa Lockwood, Blue Intrigue, Rogneid, peacestpete, Indiana Bob, CJnyc, berko, martini, kovie, tarheelblue, Medium Head Boy, Kingsmeg, dharmafarmer, cardboardurinal, Prognosticator, mskitty, KenBee, Lefty Coaster, blueoasis, SherriG, DarkestHour, triv33, MJ via Chicago, StrayCat, Ashaman, The Hindsight Times, Rosaura, gooderservice, JVolvo, NearlyNormal, el cid, hlsmlane, onionjim, BlueMississippi, CA Nana, James Hepburn, zeke7237, Clive all hat no horse Rodeo, Lovo, Cassiodorus, kurt, Ryepower12, Brunette, slakn1, Bernie68, bstotts, Friend of the court, markthshark, Little, OHdog, Aaa T Tudeattack, NonnyO, nilajean, krwheaton, One Pissed Off Liberal, dpinzow, Jarrayy, SpecialKinFlag, leema, ColoTim, offgrid, BruceMcF, EdSF, Outrider, FishOutofWater, some other george, noofsh, dclawyer06, certainot, LamontCranston, burlydee, deepeco, DWG, nookular, artisan, Kentucky Kid, getlost, jayden, SeaTurtle, bobswern, jnhobbs, millwood, CT Hank, JML9999, homerun, eyesoars, Don midwest, on the cusp, cville townie, fb, JDWolverton, MKinTN, CroneWit, JayC, misterwade, also mom of 5, flowerfarmer, wayoutinthestix, spacejam, scooter in brooklyn, zerone, OleHippieChick, bill warnick, dadadata, salamanderanagram, elwior, filby, DCBlue, jakebob, jamess, Lujane, CenFlaDem, pickandshovel, triplepoint, No Exit, temptxan, codairem, petulans, elpacifico66, 3rdOption, lenzy1000, watercarrier4diogenes, CIndyCasella, forgore, Celtic Merlin, Bule Betawi, cybrestrike, scwlaw, pvasileff, ARS, banjolele, Carol in San Antonio, CanyonWren, maryabein, Methinks They Lie, shopkeeper, dRefractor, dskoe, Shelley99, Keith Pickering, KenInCO, stevenwag, ArthurPoet, jfromga, Words In Action, Railfan, sneakers563, Just Bob, commonmass, Anima, LOrion, Lost and Found, sunny skies, Simple, Klaus, cordgrass, I Lurked For Years, gulfgal98, Lady Libertine, Kristina40, Johnny Q, Publius2008, Betty Pinson, Nada Lemming, nosleep4u, soaglow, cany, slice, Barbara Marquardt, allenjo, annominous, Lost Left Coaster, Oldowan, spooks51, slowbutsure, Susipsych, Seitanist, FarWestGirl, Nicci August, Teiresias70, Alice Olson, marleycat, Carolyn in Oregon, badscience, thomask, muddy boots, VirginiaJeff, merrily1000, tardis10, Square Knot, JayFromPA, PhilJD, sound of progress, la58, bakeneko, cailloux, Book of Hearts, Sunspots, jham710, jadt65, DRo, SouthernLiberalinMD, Take a Hard Left, BocaBlue, livingthedream, quill, chmood, Fredamae, DeadHead, CharlesII, MightyMoe, cwsmoke, Mindful Nature, SamanthaCarter, lurkyloo, Trevin, Eric Nelson, The Lone Apple, Joieau, 420 forever, congenitalefty, Horace Boothroyd III, joeschmeaux, Mr Robert, peachcreek, hotheadCA, aznavy, doh1304, rat racer, AverageJoe42, marty marty, history first, George3, wasatch, Windowpane, Robynhood too, Buckeye Liberal, madcitysailor, Raven Song, BobTheHappyDinosaur, jusjtim35, TheMeansAreTheEnd, countwebb, jbob, Late Again, eyo, poopdogcomedy, SanFernandoValleyMom, philS, gypsytoo, HedwigKos, aresea, GwenM, leeleedee, optimistic pizza, GreenMother, Demeter Rising, oslyn7, dreamweaver1, TheDuckManCometh, CenPhx, richardvjohnson, patbahn, bygorry, leoluminary, sillycarrot, EveryWoman, Choco8, WordWrangler, Petered, politically indigo, Pablo Bocanegra, ApostleOfCarlin, Genie28, JimValent, Shaylors Provence, cjtjc, BMScott, dewolf99, bobcat41702, charlatan, KDfrAZ, nicestjerk, Katannah, Kaylea, CWinebrinner, NCKath, srs105, KarenWisconsin

Subscribe or Donate to support Daily Kos.

Click here for the mobile view of the site